putin’s quest for a monroe doctrine
Last Updated : GMT 07:25:12
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today
Last Updated : GMT 07:25:12
Arab Today, arab today

Putin’s quest for a Monroe Doctrine

Arab Today, arab today

putin’s quest for a monroe doctrine

Amir Taheri

Among the questions around US President Donald Trump’s foreign policy, one stands out: What is the future of US relations with Russia? So far, Trump and members of his national security team have provided vague and at times contradictory replies. What the new administration needs to do first is decide how to clearly describe Russia. The administration of Barack Obama never made up its mind in that regard.
On occasions, such as the circus around the Iran nuclear dossier and the dodgeball Obama played on Syria, Russia was described as “our partner” by both Obama and his Secretary of State John Kerry. On other occasions, Moscow’s annexation of Crimea for example, the Obama-Kerry tandem described Russia as “a challenge.”
Russia, however, has had little difficulty labeling the US as it sees it. The adjective the Kremlin and the media under its control use to describe the US is “vrag,” which loosely translated means “foe.” That was the label Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev used against the US in the 1960s when he came out with his “we will bury you” boast.
More discerning Russians, who remember that “vrag” was used to describe Nazi Germany, prefer the less dramatic “protivnik,” which means “adversary.” More cautious commentators in Moscow suggest the still softer term “nedobrojelatie” (rival). By coincidence, the label “adversary” was used by new US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson to describe Russia during his Senate confirmation hearings.
On a spectrum of relations, a nation might place other nations in different categories. At one end there will be “friends,” nations with which one has close ties and on whose sympathy and support one can count on at all times. At any given time, few nations fall in that category. At the opposite end are “foes,” enemies bent on your destruction that must be defeated and destroyed. Again, few nations fit in that category at any given time.
The spectrum includes other categories: Adversaries, rivals, partners and allies. Such categorization is not based on hard and fast rules. At times a “friend” can act as a “rival” on specific issues, while an “adversary” might become a tactical “partner” when it is in its interest.
The task of diplomacy is to judge when and how to identify others according to a strategic vision of one’s own national interests. The goal of foreign policy is to isolate and defeat “foes,” and transform “adversaries” and “rivals” into partners, and if possible even “friends.”
The Kremlin media are wrong to describe the US as a “foe.” Even during the Cold War, few in the US wished to destroy Russia. The US tried three strategies: Containment between 1948 and 1968, détente until 1980, and rollback until the fall of the Soviet Empire.
Tillerson, however, is right: Today, Russia is an “adversary” for the US. Thus the aim of the new US administration should be to deny Moscow the opportunity to pursue adversarial policies, while at the same time the door should be open for persuading Russia to downgrade its hostility by becoming, at most, a “rival.”
The sooner that aim is spelled out, the better for all concerned. Right now, many in the Kremlin, and some circles in the West, fantasize about what they believe is Trump’s soft spot for President Vladimir Putin.
Some of Trump’s opponents have even tried to cast him as “the Moscow candidate” vulnerable to Russian blackmail (in 1828, President John Quincy Adams was accused of being a procurer for the Russian tsar during his tenure as US ambassador to Saint Petersburg).
I doubt Trump has a soft spot for Putin or anyone else except himself, and even if he did, such affection would not change the nature of the relationship between the two nations. As for blackmail material, even if Putin did have any against Trump, it is unlikely that the US will sacrifice national interests to keep a lid on any scandal.
Russia is acting as an adversary in a number of ways. It is trying to impose its version of a Monroe Doctrine on nations in the Baltics, Central and Eastern Europe, the Caucasus and Central Asia, with a mixture of proximity pressure, propaganda war, and in the cases of Georgia and Ukraine, military intervention.
Moscow has already succeeded in toppling a pro-US president in Kyrgyzstan, while halting closer ties between the US and such former Soviet republics as Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. More recently, Moscow scored another victory by propelling one of its allies into power in Armenia.
In a similar vein, Moscow has “persuaded” Azerbaijan to tone down its pro-US stance, while using the tactic of flattery with Kazakhstan toward the same goal. Putin is also trying to drive a wedge between Turkey, in its moment of confusion, and NATO allies.
Russia wants to “Finlandize” its neighbors, meaning all the former Soviet republics plus Iran and Afghanistan (throughout the Cold War, Finland accepted certain limits to its sovereignty in exchange for a guarantee it would not be invaded by the Soviets).
Weakening NATO and the EU, the two military and political pillars of the global strategy of the “free world” during the Cold War, remains one of Putin’s top goals. Trump’s ambiguous statements on NATO and the EU have encouraged that strategy. Yet the new US Secretary of Defense James Mattis has emphasized the need to “strengthen” NATO, while Tillerson has expressed support for the EU.
Putin is playing 19th century strategy, as symbolized by the meaningless 49-year lease he obtained from Bashar Assad for a naval base in Syria, in a 21st century that has no room for imperial projection of power. Obama’s pusillanimity encouraged Putin’s aggressive game, to the detriment of both Russia and the US, not to mention other nations affected.
Though Moscow is not an “enemy,” disabusing Putin of his illusions would be good not only for the US but also for Russia. Trump should welcome Russia as a rival for the US, if that is its choice, but should make clear to Putin that playing adversary will no longer be cost-free.

 

GMT 18:35 2018 Friday ,14 December

Can Armenia break the ice with Turkey?

GMT 21:25 2018 Thursday ,13 December

PM limps on with UK still in Brexit gridlock

GMT 21:21 2018 Thursday ,13 December

US begins crackdown on Iran sanctions violations

GMT 14:33 2018 Wednesday ,12 December

Political turbulence likely to continue unabated in 2019

GMT 14:26 2018 Wednesday ,12 December

Canada standing on the wrong side of history

GMT 13:27 2018 Tuesday ,11 December

France and the crisis of democracy

Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

putin’s quest for a monroe doctrine putin’s quest for a monroe doctrine

 



Arab Today, arab today Modern colorful bedroom renovation

GMT 11:23 2017 Thursday ,21 December

Modern colorful bedroom renovation
Arab Today, arab today For the Variety of Interior Design Styles

GMT 11:14 2017 Tuesday ,19 December

For the Variety of Interior Design Styles

GMT 03:20 2017 Sunday ,31 December

Gets 5-star Safety Certification

GMT 08:43 2017 Saturday ,30 December

Ahmed Mekki could not participate in Ramadan

GMT 09:13 2017 Wednesday ,09 August

Fati Jamali intensifies her drama activities

GMT 18:26 2018 Friday ,14 December

Mashrou’ Leila headline Apple event in Dubai

GMT 09:44 2017 Monday ,18 December

Worker in British embassy Found Strangled in Lebanon

GMT 08:57 2017 Wednesday ,18 October

Actress Shery Adel happy for Egypt’s qualification

GMT 08:24 2016 Tuesday ,15 November

Berlin wild charms make it first choice

GMT 15:49 2017 Friday ,18 August

Sources reveal reason behind Sherine’s absence

GMT 23:46 2016 Friday ,23 September

Weather forecast for major Chinese cities, regions

GMT 07:52 2016 Thursday ,08 December

Israel votes to advance settler homes bill

GMT 14:26 2014 Tuesday ,18 March

Global touring exhibition from Muslim Civilisation

GMT 00:33 2017 Wednesday ,09 August

Peshawar Blast Death Toll Reaches 18

GMT 13:14 2016 Tuesday ,27 December

Peru brain museum puts most complex organ on display

GMT 20:39 2017 Saturday ,10 June

Afghan commando kills two US soldiers

GMT 08:37 2017 Monday ,13 November

Jihan khalil will not participate in Ramadan

GMT 10:35 2017 Monday ,11 September

Reem Al Baroodi happy for “My Wife Fiancée”

GMT 09:11 2016 Tuesday ,30 August

France seeks halt to talks

GMT 04:45 2017 Saturday ,19 August

Racing Casablanca aspires to keep

GMT 12:28 2018 Friday ,05 January

Geagea meets Ambassadors of Egypt, Poland

GMT 11:15 2018 Wednesday ,03 January

Gibran Bassil visits Chamber of Sidon today

GMT 10:07 2018 Wednesday ,03 January

Barjees condemns Trumps’ anti Pakistan comments

GMT 04:30 2018 Wednesday ,03 January

Johannesburg suffocates in shadow of mine dumps
Arab Today, arab today
 
 Arab Today Facebook,arab today facebook  Arab Today Twitter,arab today twitter Arab Today Rss,arab today rss  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube
arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday
arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday
arabstoday
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
arabstoday, Arabstoday, Arabstoday