has secularism found a niche in iran’s qom
Last Updated : GMT 18:51:18
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today
Last Updated : GMT 18:51:18
Arab Today, arab today

Has secularism found a niche in Iran’s Qom?

Arab Today, arab today

has secularism found a niche in iran’s qom

Amir Taheri

Because it attaches the adjective “Islamic” to all its organs and whatever action it takes, the Khomeinist regime in Iran is often described as a theocracy with Shi’ism as an ideological backbone. However, what if the adjective is misplaced, not to say misleading? What if specialists have failed to note the underlying current of tension between the Islamic Republic as a political construct and traditional structures of Shi’ism?

Although Shi’ism has never had a formal organization, in the sense that Christian churches do, for example, it has, at least during the past two centuries, developed an informal apparatus of discernment and hierarchization distinct, and at times opposed, to the state machinery in place. At the heart of that apparatus is the seminary (howzah) in Arabic, a network of schools dedicated to the training of successive generations of clerics.

In February 1979 as the late Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini jumped into the void left by the Shah’s sudden departure from Iran, the assumption was that the “howzah”, as the key organ of the clerical hierarchy, will seize control of the machinery of the state through a de facto merger. However, such a merger didn’t take place.

To start with only a handful of senior ayatollahs endorsed the new Khomeimist regime, and even then not always enthusiastically. To be sure, the number of men donning turbans and fondling rosaries increased sharply as a clerical cache became a “must” for securing plum, jobs in the government. Thousands of opportunists switched from civil clothes to clerical gear and promoted themselves as Hojat al-Islam or even Ayatollah.

In 1979, the Endowments Office, a branch of the Shah’s government, estimated the number of clerics and students of theology at around 200,000. In 1989 the number had risen to almost half a million. Since it was physically impossible to train so many new mullahs one must assume that the more than doubling of the number of clerics was largely due to an influx of self-styled “holy men.”

These new “holy men” gave a visual endorsement to the new regime’s clerical claims. At the same time, however, their presence enabled the traditional clergy to maintain at least part of its independent identity.

The Khomeinist regime’s religious claims were also challenged by the fact that the seminary (howzah) in Najaf, Iraq, was beyond its control and thus capable of offering a refuge to Iranian clerics who did not share the radical political ideas of the self-styled “Imam” Khomeini.

Claim to religious legitimacy

However, as long as the new regime could threaten or bribe the “howzah’ in Qom, it could sustain at least part of its claim to religious legitimacy. To that end, the regime created a Council of Theologians, consisting of seven to nine ayatollahs chosen by the “Supreme Guide” and bolstered by generous government handouts.

However, although some of the “chosen ones” became immensely rich, they failed to secure a genuine popular following. Thus instead of the regime relying on their popularity, they relied on the regime’s money for their continued prominence.

Over the years, the Iranian “howzahs” operating in 30 cities across the nation, most notably in Qom, managed to put some blue water between themselves and the state machinery of the Islamic Republic.

The “traditionalists” refused to political positions and stayed away from such organs of the state as the Islamic Majlis, the Assembly of Experts and the Guardians’ Council. The all-important “howzah” in Najaf has gone further in putting some blue water between itself and the Khomeinist state apparatus. Its key figures, notably Grand Ayatollah Ali-Muhammad Sistani have even stopped visiting Iran.

Now finding its legitimacy challenged by popular discontent, the Islamic Republic is trying to reassert control over the traditional clerical hierarchy, most notably in Qom.

Last summer when the “holy city” became a scene of revolt against the regime, the “Supreme Guide” Ali Khamenei had to cancel a visit and ordered the Imam Sadeq Brigade to restore order. Official propaganda claimed that, by implicitly endorsing political discontent, the traditional clergy had become “secular”.

That claim was the central theme of a demonstration last August organized by Islamic Security and sponsored by the Imam Sadeq Brigade, to intimidate the traditional clergy.

Accompanied by hundreds of young clerics, the Imam Sadeq Brigade occupied the famous Faizieh School where government propagandists launched a massive attack on traditional ayatollahs and their pupils.

“The secularization of the howzah is a threat to the established order,” said Hassan Rahimpour Azghadi, a media-savvy theoretician of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. “The howzah is, in effect, colluding with secularism, perhaps unwittingly.”

The show of force in Qom included some noise about the regime’s generous financial support for clerics and students of theology with the implicit threat that, if the “howzah” sided with dissidents, it might come to an end.

The riposte by traditional clergy came in the form of a class sermon by Grand Ayatollah Muhammad Jawad Alawi Borujerdi, regarded by many as one of Qom’s top masters of theology.

“Some gentlemen claim that the howzah has become secular,” he said. “If they claim that the howzah isn’t concerned by the people’s lives, problems and anxieties, that is obviously a lie. In essence, Shi’ism is a political faith and cannot be indifferent to the people.”

In a thinly veiled attack on state-financed clerics, the ayatollah added: “Secular are those who regard obedience to anyone {in power}; those who invent ideology for the rule of the despots… Don’t expect the howzah to do what suits you!”

Further, he added: “Yes, we do discuss matters {pertaining} to state and to limits {of power}. The field of religion, just like the fields of science and art must be open and free, meaning that people should be free to debate and discuss and theorize... Sciences progress only thanks to freedom, enabling all to benefit.”

The ayatollah also called on the government to stop handouts to clerics and students of theology.

“We have always depended on people’s voluntary donations,” he said.

Within 48 hours of the grand ayatollah’s sermon, the “Supreme Guide” had dismissed Gen. Hassan Tabibi-Far as Commander of the Imam Sadeq Brigade and ordered an investigation into last August’s dubious demonstration.

Qom going “secular”? Hard to believe, although the Tehran leadership’s ignorance and arrogance could lead to unexpected reactions from the victims of its brutal cynicism and corruption.

From: Alarabiya site

GMT 15:23 2018 Saturday ,13 October

From Truman to Trump: The rise and fall of a paradigm

GMT 15:35 2018 Friday ,05 October

Has Secularism Found a Niche in Qom?

GMT 12:41 2018 Saturday ,29 September

Iran’s choice Between Syria and Pakistan

GMT 03:42 2018 Monday ,24 September

Starry-eyed Putin between fact and fantasy on Syria

GMT 11:10 2018 Friday ,21 September

"Syria" Putin Between Fact and Fantasy

Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

has secularism found a niche in iran’s qom has secularism found a niche in iran’s qom


Arab Today, arab today Modern colorful bedroom renovation

GMT 11:23 2017 Thursday ,21 December

Modern colorful bedroom renovation
Arab Today, arab today Burberry revamps under new designer Riccardo Tisci

GMT 15:11 2018 Tuesday ,18 September

Burberry revamps under new designer Riccardo Tisci
Arab Today, arab today For the Variety of Interior Design Styles

GMT 11:14 2017 Tuesday ,19 December

For the Variety of Interior Design Styles
Arab Today, arab today Facebook says security flaw affected 50 million accounts

GMT 13:39 2015 Wednesday ,18 November

Turkey kills 'Daesh militant' on Syria border, detains 21

GMT 17:49 2017 Friday ,14 July

Saad Lamjarred denied issuance of new song

GMT 14:47 2017 Wednesday ,12 April

Baghdad neglected Historical Buildings cry for help

GMT 16:35 2017 Thursday ,19 January

Maguy Bou Ghosn says Welaane achieved great success

GMT 09:17 2018 Saturday ,13 January

1.5 C climate goal 'very unlikely' but doable

GMT 01:45 2018 Saturday ,13 January

Saudi women to attend football game

GMT 06:38 2018 Tuesday ,09 January

H&M removes 'black boy' ad after racism accusation

GMT 10:52 2018 Monday ,08 January

Eyeko appoints Emerge for latest launch

GMT 16:54 2013 Tuesday ,18 June

I prefer the old Egyptian government

GMT 16:26 2017 Tuesday ,28 November

US new home sales rise to 10-year high

GMT 09:06 2018 Saturday ,13 January

Plot twist as Pakistani soap operas seek

GMT 07:31 2017 Tuesday ,05 December

Actress Menna Shalaby reveals her coming works

GMT 04:31 2018 Wednesday ,24 January

Qatar backs Turkey's military action against Kurds

GMT 09:30 2018 Tuesday ,16 January

We fear Sterling more than Kane

GMT 08:40 2018 Sunday ,14 January

Tesla faces fresh Norway lawsuit

GMT 03:55 2018 Saturday ,13 January

Trump 'desperate' to undermine nuclear

GMT 04:35 2018 Wednesday ,03 January

No rise in autism in US in past three years

GMT 10:27 2017 Tuesday ,03 October

Singer Nawal Al Zoghbi happy for receiving honor

GMT 10:00 2018 Tuesday ,23 January

Kanso: We are sure we will win

GMT 09:11 2018 Saturday ,20 January

Failed ski resort looms over Pyeongchang Games' legacy
Arab Today, arab today
 Arab Today Facebook,arab today facebook  Arab Today Twitter,arab today twitter Arab Today Rss,arab today rss  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube
arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday
arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
arabstoday, Arabstoday, Arabstoday