Apple Samsung challenge in US trade panel

Apple prevailed Friday at a US trade panel in a patent infringement complaint filed by South Korea's Samsung over wireless communication technology for the iPhone and other Apple devices. A judge at the US International Trade Commission, a quasi-judicial agency which investigates trade complaints, found "no violation" by Apple of the patents for wireless communication devices and tablet computers, said a statement on the preliminary ruling. The ruling by administrative judge James Gildea is subject to review by the full commission. It was the latest victory for Silicon Valley-based Apple, which last month won a massive patent lawsuit against Samsung in a California court, which ordered Samsung to pay more than $1 billion for patent infringement. A series of legal battles are pending around the world, including claims by Samsung that Apple illegally used the South Korean electronics firm's wireless communications technology. The ITC has the authority to ban imports of devices if it finds patent infringement. Florian Mueller, a patent consultant who follows technology issues, said the case was another setback for the South Korean giant. "Samsung was hoping (and despite today's setback will continue to hope) to gain some leverage over Apple from an ITC import ban," he wrote in a blog post. "And in light of the recent California trial, Samsung needs leverage sooner rather than later." The judge in the California Apple-Samsung case set a December 6 hearing on punitive damages to the US firm for patent infringement and on whether to ban eight Samsung phones in the US market. Apple has asked the court to ban some of the newer 4G phones from Samsung's Galaxy line in the case. Samsung has said it would appeal and has pledged to fight the proposed ban.