working with assad to do what
Last Updated : GMT 23:45:38
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today

Working with Assad to do what?

Arab Today, arab today

working with assad to do what

Amir Taheri

The recent US missile attack on a Syrian regime air base may or may not have been a turning point in American foreign policy, but it surely put the thorny issue of President Bashar Assad’s future back on the diplomatic agenda. By hitting the air base in the wake of the chemical attack on Idlib, US President Donald Trump enforced the “red line” declared and abandoned by his predecessor Barack Obama.

Will Trump also try to enforce another loudly declared and quietly dropped Obama position, that Assad has no role in Syria’s future? Obama started his “Assad must step down” mantra in 2012, to the delight of State Department and Pentagon officials who believed that unless the dictator left, Syria would not calm down. By 2013, however, Obama had reformulated his mantra to read “Assad must step aside.”

Track-II secret talks were held about a formula under which Assad would remain head of state but hand over power to one of his vice presidents, who would lead a Cabinet of technocrats tasked to work on a new constitution, followed by elections. Yet by 2015, Obama had forgotten all that, accepting Assad’s presence well into an undetermined future.

The Syrian tragedy is, in great part, a result of Assad’s opportunistic and cowardly decision to adopt the position of the most radical elements of his Baathist regime. Between 2011 and 2015, dozens of Syrian officials, some with decades of service under Assad’s father, tried to develop formulae to help all parties in the civil war forge a compromise. Assad, maybe under duress, refused to budge, ensuring that the carnage continued.

Many of those officials either quietly faded into the background or fled into exile. Assad remained at the center of a coterie of sanguinary sectarians increasingly beholden to Iranian mullahs and, from 2014 onward, the “big bear” in the Kremlin. Today, in terms of actual power, Assad has become largely irrelevant. He is little more than a mask of pseudo-legality for Moscow and Tehran for their common, yet contradictory, designs for Syria.

Outside Russia and Iran, some, including the usual suspects in the perennial anti-West movement, use Assad as a theme to confuse public opinion regarding the Syrian tragedy. Some advocates of realpolitik, such as Julian Lewis, who chairs the defense committee in the British House of Commons, start with a prologue about how evil Assad is, but end up saying the world should nevertheless work with him.

Since the “work” Assad is doing largely consists of killing people, Lewis should also say how the British could help him do that. Lewis says during World War II, Britain forged an alliance with Stalin to fight Hitler, forgetting the Soviet despot’s blood-soaked record. But the MP forgets that Stalin had signed an alliance with Hitler, the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, and was dragged into the war only after Germany invaded the USSR.

When that happened, it was Stalin who begged the British, and later the Americans, to help him stop the Nazi juggernaut. He controlled vast expanses of land and millions of young men to be used as cannon fodder. Assad has neither. He barely controls about 15 percent of Syrian territory, and has publicly admitted he lacks the manpower to extend his rule.

Without the estimated 60,000 Lebanese, Afghan, Pakistani and other mercenaries mobilized by Tehran, Assad would not be able to defend even his lair in Damascus. And without Russia’s air force enlisted to carpet-bomb Aleppo and other Syrian cities, Lewis’ putative Syrian ally would have never been able to hoist his flag there. More importantly perhaps, Assad is fighting the majority of the Syrian people, who could hardly be called “Nazis.”

What interest does Britain or any other democracy have in letting the carnage continue in Syria? In realpolitik terms, Assad is a diminished figure; each day that passes sees him shrink further into insignificance.

Another argument used in defense of the “we must work with Assad” formula is advanced by Francois Fillon, the beleaguered right-wing candidate in the French presidential election. He says the West should “work with Assad” because he represents Syria’s legal government.

But how did Assad gain legality? There has never been a genuine election in Syria, and Assad was simply declared president to succeed his father, in violation of the constitution. But even if Assad’s legality were not doubtful, such legality should not give carte blanche for the commission of war crimes and crimes against humanity. After all, Hitler’s government was legal because he had once won a general election.

Russian President Vladimir Putin advances another argument: Assad is fighting “terrorists” and deserves to be supported. But it is now clear that Assad’s forces, and their Russian and Iranian backers, have taken no meaningful action against Daesh, the arch-terrorist group still in control of large chunks of Syrian territory. It is far-fetched to suggest that 80 percent of Syrians who oppose Assad are all terrorists.

The millions of refugees and displaced persons — most of them women, children and the elderly — are ordinary human beings who want a bit of freedom and security to live their lives. Assad and Daesh, and other smaller terrorist groups, have deprived them of that. Assad no longer has a place in Syria. Even if he were handed all of Syria on a platter, he does not have enough supporters to establish control and recreate a minimum of government.

As a state, Syria has already died. A new Syrian state must be created. Neither Assad, Daesh nor the two-dozen or so armed groups fighting him can assume that task on their own. But Assad’s departure could open a space for all Syrians, including the minority that backed him, to come together to tackle that awesome task. In both moral and realpolitik terms, “Assad must go” is a reasonable formula for ending the Syrian tragedy.


Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

working with assad to do what working with assad to do what


Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today AnOther Magazine names fashion coordinator

GMT 10:28 2017 Thursday ,14 December

AnOther Magazine names fashion coordinator
Arab Today, arab today In trouble as Lufthansa drops bid

GMT 13:59 2017 Sunday ,17 December

In trouble as Lufthansa drops bid
Arab Today, arab today 3 Ways to Find the Best Interior Design Ideas

GMT 09:49 2017 Tuesday ,12 December

3 Ways to Find the Best Interior Design Ideas
Arab Today, arab today Fatah calls for protests against US

GMT 14:23 2017 Sunday ,17 December

Fatah calls for protests against US
Arab Today, arab today Uber denied new license in northern

GMT 13:44 2017 Sunday ,17 December

Uber denied new license in northern
Arab Today, arab today Dubai’s first ever ‘Modest Fashion Week’ draws

GMT 11:26 2017 Tuesday ,12 December

Dubai’s first ever ‘Modest Fashion Week’ draws
Arab Today, arab today Flights between Russia &Egypt to resume

GMT 02:52 2017 Saturday ,16 December

Flights between Russia &Egypt to resume
Arab Today, arab today Why You Should Choose Oriental

GMT 10:36 2017 Wednesday ,29 November

Why You Should Choose Oriental
Arab Today, arab today Dutch police open fire on man with knife

GMT 03:07 2017 Saturday ,16 December

Dutch police open fire on man with knife
Arab Today, arab today Polish regulator defends TV channel's fine

GMT 09:49 2017 Saturday ,16 December

Polish regulator defends TV channel's fine
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today

GMT 03:23 2017 Wednesday ,06 December

Cleric praises mosque school idea

GMT 04:18 2017 Sunday ,26 November

Bella magazine appoints celebrity writer

GMT 15:24 2017 Thursday ,05 October


GMT 04:30 2017 Sunday ,22 October

Miista appoints IPR London

GMT 15:05 2017 Thursday ,05 October

Haddon PR handles Deskmate

GMT 16:33 2014 Thursday ,13 November

Al-Ehtimam Bil Aakhareen

GMT 06:00 2017 Sunday ,29 October

Childrenswear brand Once appoints Dyelog

GMT 16:08 2017 Tuesday ,24 October

Glamour fashion editor goes freelance

GMT 09:12 2017 Friday ,17 November

Gleam Futures represents Grace Beverley

GMT 03:34 2017 Sunday ,05 November

Needle & Thread relocates press office

GMT 08:16 2017 Saturday ,02 December

MP warns of new drug spread in Egypt

GMT 05:14 2017 Thursday ,19 October

Blogger seeks male beauty boxes for Christmas Gift

GMT 05:29 2017 Wednesday ,27 September names fashion editor and marketing manager

GMT 15:12 2017 Saturday ,14 October

Christmas Gift Guide - My Girls On Tour

GMT 08:32 2017 Thursday ,30 November

MP calls for withdrawing confidence

GMT 06:03 2014 Wednesday ,09 April

Please .. Let Gaza breathe!

GMT 12:20 2017 Tuesday ,05 December

Amara underlined role of construction

GMT 06:56 2017 Friday ,01 December

Minister stresses refusal to Benkiran

GMT 13:56 2017 Friday ,01 December

Trump fuels Tillerson firing speculation

GMT 07:31 2017 Tuesday ,05 December

Actress Menna Shalaby reveals her coming works

GMT 16:48 2017 Saturday ,09 December

Al Zaydi underlines Huthi role in prices

GMT 04:06 2017 Tuesday ,05 December

Kuwait prepares for hosting GCC Summit

GMT 01:41 2017 Saturday ,12 August

Moroccan video sparks debate on sexual harassment
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today
 Arab Today Facebook,arab today facebook  Arab Today Twitter,arab today twitter Arab Today Rss,arab today rss  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube
arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday
arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
arabstoday, Arabstoday, Arabstoday