Arab Today, arab today arab writers rally in defence of mahfouz following criticisms
Last Updated : GMT 19:53:43
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today

Arab writers rally in defence of Mahfouz following criticisms

Arab Today, arab today

Arab Today, arab today Arab writers rally in defence of Mahfouz following criticisms

Cairo - Arabstoday

Recent statements by Palestinian poet and critic Salma Alkhadra about acclaimed Egyptian novelist and Nobel laureate Naguib Mahfouz, in which she cast aspersions on the latter\'s literary merits, have evoked angry responses in Egypt and the Arab world. In an interview with literary journal Shoroufat, Alkhadra asserted that Mahfouz \"isn’t an interesting writer or a great novelist, although he has enthralled [readers] on the basis of the Arabic novel.” She also said that writer Amin Maalouf was \"more interesting\" than Mahfouz, and attributed Mahfouz\'s winning of the Nobel Prize for Literature to \"chance.\" Literary critic Shaaban Youssef described Alkhadra\'s statements as “a continuation of the smear campaigns that aim to tarnish Mahfouz\'s value to Arabic literature in recent years. Writer Edward El-Kharrat underrated Mahfouz’s talent, which he called \'average,\' even to the point of saying that, if there were an Arab writer who deserved the Nobel Prize, it would be El-Kharrat himself or Syrian poet Adonis.” Youssef went on to describe Alkhadra\'s comments as \"strange.\" \"When she says Mahfouz was neither interesting nor great, these are relative things differing from one reader to another, but it’s not a critical judgment,\" he said. \"I could only classify it as an impression lacking sobriety and critical accuracy.\" Nor are comparisons between Mahfouz and Maalouf appropriate, said Youssef, since they both belong to different traditions of writing. \"Alkhadra wanted media hype because she wants attention, but this is her last dance on the media stage,\" said Youssef. Alkhadra\'s statements \"have no credibility,\" opined Iraqi novelist Ali Badr, explaining that Nobel Prize archives had revealed since 2000 that the committee had first decided to grant Mahfouz the prize in 1988. \"The committee was tending towards Adonis at first. By that time there was only one work about Mahfouz, published in English by Jewish writer Sasson Somikh,\" said Badr. \"After that the committee sent the Swedish ambassador’s wife to Cairo to contact some literary experts, one of whom was Dennis Johnson Davis, in front of whom three names were posited: Mahfouz, Adonis and Sudanese writer Tayyib Saleh. Davis told her that Tayyib Saleh had only one good novel; that Adonis was a great poet but not accessible to the average reader; and that Mahfouz was the only one who had both considerable literary merit and a wide readership.\" But according to Tariq Imam, a young writer, Mahfouz isn’t above criticism, and every reader has the right to criticise his work. Yet the problem, for Imam, lies in Alkhardra\'s credibility. \"For me, there’s something lacking in what she said, and we don’t know what pushed her to say this,\" he said. Moroccan poet Naguib Khadary, for his part, said: “I don’t know what to believe. But what we learn from history is that big events have many narrators, and these narrations often contradict each other. Some of these narrators are honest, some are liars; some are objective, while others are subjective – even deceptive.” Saying that Mahfouz wasn’t a great writer is “far from the truth” as Sudanese author Tariq Attayib said, since \"it isn\'t logical that the man credited with setting the basis for the Arabic novel wasn’t a great writer.\"

Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

Arab Today, arab today arab writers rally in defence of mahfouz following criticisms Arab Today, arab today arab writers rally in defence of mahfouz following criticisms

 



Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today Saudis await visitors but will they come?

GMT 11:54 2017 Thursday ,23 February

Saudis await visitors but will they come?
Arab Today, arab today Sarah Belamesh designs antiques of "ceramic"

GMT 19:45 2017 Monday ,20 February

Sarah Belamesh designs antiques of "ceramic"
Arab Today, arab today Blind sheikh buried in Egypt

GMT 06:32 2017 Thursday ,23 February

Blind sheikh buried in Egypt
Arab Today, arab today Media host Mona Iraqi stresses her show's success

GMT 15:32 2017 Wednesday ,22 February

Media host Mona Iraqi stresses her show's success
View News in Arabic - Culture: أحداث ثقافية
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today To hold social dialogue over secondary school

GMT 07:43 2017 Wednesday ,22 February

To hold social dialogue over secondary school
Arab Today, arab today UK appoints 1st Scotland Yard chief in 188 years

GMT 05:14 2017 Thursday ,23 February

UK appoints 1st Scotland Yard chief in 188 years
Arab Today, arab today Ex-yoga missionary unleashes rage

GMT 12:16 2017 Thursday ,23 February

Ex-yoga missionary unleashes rage
Arab Today, arab today Pluto's unruly moons

GMT 06:31 2015 Thursday ,04 June

Pluto's unruly moons
Arab Today, arab today Tesla back into red but revenue grows

GMT 07:27 2017 Thursday ,23 February

Tesla back into red but revenue grows
Arab Today, arab today Nissan enhances sales in most markets

GMT 14:08 2017 Monday ,20 February

Nissan enhances sales in most markets
Arab Today, arab today Salma Rashid happy for 'A Whisper of Love'

GMT 05:19 2017 Tuesday ,21 February

Salma Rashid happy for 'A Whisper of Love'
Arab Today, arab today Milan laughs while Rome cries

GMT 10:28 2017 Wednesday ,22 February

Milan laughs while Rome cries

GMT 06:41 2017 Monday ,20 February

Janat pleased for issuing 'Good Morning'

GMT 12:35 2017 Tuesday ,21 February

63-Year-Old Woman Delivers Baby

GMT 14:29 2017 Monday ,20 February

Prepares to present her new collection

GMT 15:53 2017 Tuesday ,21 February

Small ponds have outsized impact

GMT 23:29 2017 Thursday ,16 February

Home built on sand castles-style costs $8m

GMT 07:51 2017 Wednesday ,22 February

Mom's immune system accepts babies

GMT 17:46 2017 Saturday ,18 February

Tourist guide reveals methods of tourist attractions

GMT 13:12 2015 Saturday ,09 May

Sheikh Sultan opens Sharjah Centre

GMT 19:10 2017 Friday ,17 February

Hats, scarves add beauty to women
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today
 
 Arab Today Facebook,arab today facebook  Arab Today Twitter,arab today twitter Arab Today Rss,arab today rss  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube
arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday
arabstoday arabstoday arabstoday
arabstoday
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
arabstoday, Arabstoday, Arabstoday